Thursday, October 13, 2005

A Lightweight In A Heavyweight Arena



The United States Supreme Court is to judging what the heavyweight class is to boxing. There may be lightweights out there who are great boxers, but they just don't have the size to take on the big guns. Evander Holyfield will never be put in the ring with Oscar De La Jolla. Nothing against Oscar, he's got great experience as a boxer, but he's going to get pummelled with such a mismatch. Likewise, there may be intelligent judges out there who are great on the state courts or even in the appellate courts, but they may not be intellectually heavy enough for the U.S. Supreme Court.

Debating the John Roberts and Harriett Miers nominations for the Supreme Court has begged the ultimate question of what qualifications are required for the high court. Since the Founding Fathers offered no help on the question, everyone has offered their $.02 on the matter depending upon the result they want. According to the Emperor, one need only be his friend, agree with "strict constructionism" (although I bet the Monkey-in-Chief has no idea what that means) and be a Christian to be on the Court. It has nothing to do with having heavyweights on the Court. It has everything to do with finding someone who parrots the Bush Administration party line and emasculates the Constitutional separation of powers and independence of the judiciary. No, I am not jumping to conclusions. Bush's requirement list conspicuously excludes the most critical requirement for the job -- an intellectual heavyweight.

When I was in law school, Constitutional Law undoubtedly was one of the most challenging classes we took. The reason being, of course, is that many opinions were written in the late 1800's and were 50 pages long. Good luck trying to make heads or tails out of that as a first year law student or as a lawyer, for that matter. Even many of the modern opinions offer little clarity for the student, let alone the practitioners and lower courts who must refer to these opinions for guidance, because of result-oriented reasoning or lack of clarity in thought. For fun, try reading one Supreme Court decision here. A Supreme Court judge must read thousands of these opinions and write analyses based upon them. Not anyone can do it.

For the non-lawyers reading this, legal opinions are generally made up of the following four components: facts, issue, reasoning and holding (i.e. conclusion). When a judge makes her decision, she lays out these four factors so that those who read it understand not only what she decided but WHY. It is the why, the reasoning, that forms the crux of stare decisis (precedent that must be followed). And it is the why, the reasoning, that distinguishes a legal scholar from a crony appointment.

I have yet to hear from anyone who supports Miers that she is an intellectual powerhouse. Indeed, the super loonie reich wingers are angry about her nomination because there are judges, whether you agree with them or not, who have proven track records of having the intellectual standards to be in the Ring of 9. Miers may be a fantastic lawyer, but one can only assume that the silence about her intelligence means something. The Texas Lottery Commission does not make you an intellectual heavyweight. Nor does being White House Counsel. Thus, the inquiry has been focused on where she goes to church and whether she opposes abortion.

When the hearings on Miers' nomination get underway, the only thing that matters is what weight class she belongs in. My guess is that she will be a featherweight vying for a place among heavyweights.

15 Comments:

At 7:04 AM, October 14, 2005 , Blogger Capt. Fogg said...

Her fulsome praise of Bush is enough to make one question her intelligence, if not her sanity and honesty as well.

 
At 7:47 AM, October 14, 2005 , Blogger mrsleep said...

II, excellent point. Lightweight/Heavy weight analogy.

Could be applied to our Commander in Chief as well. Kerry as well unfortunately was a lightweight.

I like Roberts.

I'm hoping Miers is pulled an someone of substance is recommended next. We need a true knock down drag out fight in the Senate. We have to flush the process out.

 
At 2:16 PM, October 14, 2005 , Blogger Stalin the Shark said...

The crucial issue with Miers, from where I stand, is separation of powers. There's a reason why no WH counsel has ever made it on to the Court; it implies too much deference to the executive branch.

I don't think that she'll even make it out of committee. The rumblings from the Senate are very displeased at the moment.

:-), StS

 
At 4:10 PM, October 14, 2005 , Blogger Intellectual Insurgent said...

If Miers gets pulled, expect to see one of the crazies from the 4th Circuit. Then again, maybe GW will decide to piss off the religious loonies again and nominate Gonzalez.

 
At 10:57 PM, October 14, 2005 , Blogger Reign of Reason said...

Good points...

I find it fascinating that the conservatives on the court have overturned laws far more often that the 'activist judges' Bush keeps harping about.

I don't have the data reference here tonight, but I believe the conservatives have been 'active' by more than a 2-1 margin as compared to their more liberal colleagues.

Just another point that what Bush and conservatives really want is someone who'll oppose Roe and help put god into government.

 
At 6:31 PM, October 16, 2005 , Blogger The State Of . . . said...

Very good. She's definitely not part of the legal elite that one needs to be in order to be confirmed. SMU law school simply carries no weight, so she has no support network.

 
At 9:48 PM, December 05, 2014 , Blogger oakleyses said...

polo ralph lauren, prada outlet, oakley vault, christian louboutin shoes, cheap oakley sunglasses, tory burch outlet online, true religion, michael kors outlet, coach outlet, prada handbags, michael kors outlet online, chanel handbags, louis vuitton outlet, tiffany jewelry, gucci handbags, burberry outlet online, kate spade outlet, michael kors outlet online, coach outlet store online, michael kors handbags, oakley sunglasses, louis vuitton outlet online, tiffany and co jewelry, longchamp outlet online, ray ban sunglasses, michael kors outlet store, louis vuitton, nike air max, longchamp outlet, red bottom shoes, true religion outlet, polo ralph lauren outlet, jordan shoes, michael kors outlet online, nike outlet, ray ban outlet, christian louboutin, nike free, nike air max, burberry outlet online, kate spade outlet online, louis vuitton outlet, coach outlet, longchamp handbags, louis vuitton handbags, coach purses, christian louboutin outlet

 
At 9:51 PM, December 05, 2014 , Blogger oakleyses said...

converse pas cher, nike roshe run, hermes pas cher, nike roshe, true religion outlet, ray ban pas cher, north face, nike air force, guess pas cher, mulberry, scarpe hogan, hollister, true religion jeans, ralph lauren pas cher, ralph lauren, sac michael kors, burberry pas cher, hollister, louis vuitton pas cher, michael kors uk, oakley pas cher, air max pas cher, nike free, michael kors canada, louis vuitton, nike air max, sac vanessa bruno, nike air max, chaussure louboutin, north face pas cher, vans pas cher, air jordan, nike blazer pas cher, longchamp pas cher, sac louis vuitton, louis vuitton uk, lululemon, tn pas cher, longchamp, air max, ray ban uk, lacoste pas cher, abercrombie and fitch, timberland, new balance pas cher, barbour, nike free pas cher

 
At 9:57 PM, December 05, 2014 , Blogger oakleyses said...

babyliss, new balance outlet, replica watches, vans outlet, mcm handbags, celine handbags, beats headphones, nike trainers, nfl jerseys, giuseppe zanotti, jimmy choo shoes, ugg boots, birkin bag, asics shoes, canada goose outlet, ferragamo shoes, insanity workout, nike huarache, chi flat iron, hollister, abercrombie and fitch, uggs outlet, north face jackets, north face jackets, mac cosmetics, soccer jerseys, canada goose outlet, uggs outlet, uggs on sale, bottega veneta, instyler ionic styler, ugg boots clearance, nike roshe, valentino shoes, lululemon outlet, ugg, marc jacobs outlet, ugg outlet, longchamp, ghd, reebok shoes, ugg soldes, p90x workout, soccer shoes, wedding dresses, mont blanc pens, herve leger, canada goose outlet, canada goose

 
At 10:04 PM, December 05, 2014 , Blogger oakleyses said...

ugg, gucci, canada goose, iphone 6 case, hollister canada, vans, canada goose, swarovski uk, pandora jewelry, air max, ray ban, pandora charms, moncler, timberland shoes, moncler outlet, moncler, canada goose, replica watches, louis vuitton canada, uggs canada, coach outlet, juicy couture outlet, converse shoes, thomas sabo uk, nike air max, juicy couture outlet, ralph lauren, hollister clothing, moncler, hollister, supra shoes, louboutin, toms outlet, oakley, canada goose pas cher, parajumpers outlet, moncler, wedding dress, baseball bats, converse, swarovski jewelry, links of london uk, lancel, moncler outlet, pandora uk, karen millen, moncler, montre femme

 
At 6:53 PM, September 23, 2015 , Blogger ninest123 Ninest said...

ninest123 09.24
oakley sunglasses, tiffany jewelry, tory burch outlet, ray ban sunglasses, ray ban sunglasses, louboutin shoes, michael kors outlet, oakley sunglasses, burberry outlet online, michael kors outlet, replica watches, louis vuitton, louis vuitton outlet, uggs on sale, oakley sunglasses, longchamp outlet, michael kors outlet, burberry, polo ralph lauren outlet, replica watches, michael kors outlet, christian louboutin outlet, oakley sunglasses, nike air max, gucci outlet, louis vuitton, michael kors outlet, ugg boots, tiffany and co, cheap oakley sunglasses, longchamp, longchamp outlet, prada outlet, ray ban sunglasses, louboutin outlet, prada handbags, ugg boots, nike air max, ugg boots, polo ralph lauren outlet, louis vuitton, louis vuitton outlet, ugg boots, nike outlet, michael kors, jordan shoes, louboutin

 
At 6:55 PM, September 23, 2015 , Blogger ninest123 Ninest said...

burberry, new balance pas cher, michael kors, coach outlet, sac longchamp, true religion jeans, mulberry, oakley pas cher, ralph lauren pas cher, louboutin pas cher, ralph lauren uk, nike free run uk, north face, true religion jeans, michael kors, ray ban pas cher, true religion jeans, sac guess, nike air max, air jordan pas cher, vans pas cher, nike air max, nike free, tn pas cher, coach factory outlet, air max, coach purses, nike roshe run, chanel handbags, coach outlet, hollister pas cher, converse pas cher, abercrombie and fitch, north face, true religion outlet, nike blazer, hogan, kate spade outlet, hermes, longchamp pas cher, lululemon, nike air max, timberland, nike free, hollister, michael kors, michael kors, kate spade handbags, air force, ray ban uk, lacoste pas cher

 
At 6:59 PM, September 23, 2015 , Blogger ninest123 Ninest said...

instyler, nike air max, oakley, ferragamo shoes, herve leger, jimmy choo shoes, nike huarache, giuseppe zanotti, celine handbags, mcm handbags, hollister, north face outlet, ray ban, beats by dre, hollister, converse outlet, vans shoes, nike roshe, hollister, soccer shoes, lancel, ralph lauren, louboutin, insanity workout, valentino shoes, new balance, wedding dresses, mont blanc, abercrombie and fitch, asics running shoes, reebok shoes, chi flat iron, longchamp, nike air max, nike trainers, north face outlet, converse, p90x workout, soccer jerseys, vans, timberland boots, mac cosmetics, lululemon, ghd, baseball bats, nfl jerseys, birkin bag, nike roshe, gucci, babyliss, iphone 6 cases, bottega veneta, vanessa bruno

 
At 7:01 PM, September 23, 2015 , Blogger ninest123 Ninest said...

pandora jewelry, marc jacobs, moncler outlet, coach outlet, canada goose, replica watches, bottes ugg, michael kors outlet online, canada goose, pandora charms, wedding dresses, ugg boots uk, doudoune canada goose, canada goose outlet, moncler, karen millen, louis vuitton, moncler, links of london, pandora jewelry, moncler, michael kors outlet, toms shoes, moncler, barbour, ugg pas cher, ugg,ugg australia,ugg italia, louis vuitton, supra shoes, swarovski crystal, juicy couture outlet, montre pas cher, thomas sabo, doke gabbana outlet, ugg,uggs,uggs canada, canada goose, louis vuitton, moncler, sac louis vuitton pas cher, canada goose outlet, swarovski, michael kors handbags, hollister, canada goose uk, juicy couture outlet, moncler, moncler, canada goose, louis vuitton, barbour jackets, pandora charms
ninest123 09.24

 
At 12:29 AM, November 13, 2017 , Blogger raybanoutlet001 said...

nba jerseys
coach outlet online
coach outlet online
cheap ray bans
nike shoes
snapbacks wholesale
ray ban sunglasses
cheap jordan shoes
oakley sunglasses
nike outlet

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home